This is the second key fob protector I've bought in the past year. A lot of the ones you find on Amazon don't have a secure way of closing the protector - just a flimsy elastic bandy thing, and are only available in black, which makes them harder to find if you drop or misplace the protector. And that's exactly what happened with my first one. I dropped the protector in our yard by accident at night (luckily the key wasn't in it) and didn't find it again until a few weeks later. By which point it was musty and dirty from being out in the humidity for so long. I put it in the wash, only to discover that washing it destroyed the shielding.
The Silent Pocket protector meets all three criteria (well 2 out 3 for sure, anyway). It's available in a range of colors, and seems to be well made. The durable canvas material has a quality feel, and I was able to verify that it works as advertised. With the key in the protector (you have to slip it inside the bronze-ish shielded pocket) and the cover snapped shut, I couldn't open my car even from 1 foot away. Even with the cover open, the key wasn't being recognized. Sweet!
The clasping mechanism is really nice. It snaps shut and holds the protector closed more securely than competing products that just have an elastic band. It adds a quality touch and works really well. What's more is that there are two more snaps on the back, which allow you to essentially fold the protector in half to make it more compact.
